Nancy Guthrie missing case: Nancy Guthrie disappearance has taken a chilling turn, with investigators now exploring whether a nearby vacant house was used to plan the crime. In a case that has already generated tens of thousands of tips and a $1 million reward, this new theory suggests the incident may not have been random at all. Authorities believe the 84-year-old was abducted during a narrow early-morning window on February 1, 2026, after being last seen the night before. The presence of blood at the scene, combined with missing surveillance footage and a masked suspect, points toward a carefully executed operation.