Computerworld NZ

WhatsApp X (Twitter) Facebook Telegram Link

Trump’s new AI order — hallucinations aren’t just for LLMs

Years ago, right-wingers coined the phrase “Trump Derangement Syndrome” (TDS) to describe people who hate US President Donald J. Trump. (I think it better describes the president’s outlandish, truth-challenged statements and the followers who think he can do no wrong.) What’s really deranged is his recent AI executive order . First, a little history. As you may recall, Trump often (and loudly) trashed his predecessor’s Executive Order 14110 , which had demanded “safe, secure, and trustworthy” AI. That Biden Administration order was replaced last year by Trump’s own “ Removing Barriers to American Leadership in Artificial Intelligence ” directive; it basically let US AI companies do whatever they wanted in the name of innovation. Then, a little thing called Anthropic Mythos came along — and scared the pants off even AI’s biggest fans. Seemingly in response, someone in the federal government decided that letting AI companies do whatever they want might not be the brightest policy. Or, did they? True, the new order creates a process under which AI companies can give US  government access to “covered frontier models” for up to 30 days before public release so experts can probe for vulnerabilities and test how the systems could be abused. It also directs agencies to set evaluation standards, establish an “AI cybersecurity clearinghouse,” and harden federal networks against rapidly advancing AI‑enabled attacks. Some people, like Graham Brookie , vice president for technology programs and strategy at the Atlantic Council, think the order is great. “The administration’s executive order on Advanced AI Innovation and Security is a serious policy with support from necessary stakeholders across party lines and industry to ensure the government is evaluating the cybersecurity risks posed by frontier AI models. It’s a policy that can be built on. ” Really? I’m not sure Brookie read the same document I did — if, indeed, he read it at all. I quote: “Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize the creation of a mandatory governmental licensing, preclearance, or permitting requirement for the development, publication, release, or distribution of new AI models, including frontier models. “In addition, ‘This order is not intended to, and does not, create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law or in equity by any party against the United States, its departments, agencies, or entities, its officers, employees, or agents, or any other person.’” In other words, AI companies won’t be required to do much of anything. And if they do submit a project for review, get the government’s blessing for it, and something goes badly wrong, it’s not the government’s fault. So, exactly why would AI companies even mess with this performative AI security theater? Beyond those concerns, who exactly will be judging AI projects in 30 days? In theory, it would be a cybersecurity clearinghouse made up of people from the National Security Agency, the US Treasury Department, and the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) . Most likely, CISA would do the bulk of the heavy-lifting — it’s their job, after all. But there’s this wee problem; Trump’s so-called Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) last year gutted CISA . There’s virtually no one left to do the work, and certainly not in 30 days. There’s also the question of funding for the new initiative.  According to the order, “The Director of OMB, in coordination with the National Cyber Director and the Director of CISA, shall determine whether any Federal grant programs have available and relevant funding that can be directed toward applicants developing advanced AI vulnerability detection.” Spoiler: There’s no money set aside for this purpose. Leaving aside whether the Executive Order has any teeth at all — the Brennan Center for Justice argued that under the Constitution, it doesn’t ; the closer you look at the document, the less substance you’ll find. Besides, in an industry where success is all about releasing the latest Large Language Model (LLM) as fast as possible to garner attention and investor dollars, who exactly would want to put their AI models on ice for even 30 days? (Short answer: No one.) These companies are always going to be focused first on getting the word out about their latest model as fast as humanly — Uh, AI-ly — possible. Still, some people seem to think this executive order really will make a difference. For example, Paul Benda , the American Bankers Association executive vice president for risk, fraud, and cybersecurity, sees it “ as a constructive step toward strengthening the nation’s approach to managing the cybersecurity risks and opportunities associated with advanced artificial intelligence [because it ] can help better protect critical infrastructure, including the financial sector.” Oh, please. I’m so tired of people who skim the titles of Trump’s executive orders and then assume there’s anything real about them. This AI order is meaningless garbage, and anyone telling you otherwise is either lying or wants to be on the Trump regime’s good (?) side. Or, both — it could always be both.

Google Play App Store